Peeps Skillet Smores

The first time I brought these to a dinner party, my friend Sarah actually gasped when I pulled the skillet from the oven. The Peeps had expanded into this golden, puffy cloud over the chocolate, and suddenly our ordinary Tuesday night felt like a celebration. Now whenever I spot those colorful marshmallow chicks appearing in grocery store aisles, I know exactly what destiny awaits them.

Last spring during a particularly rainy weekend, my kids were bouncing off the walls and I needed something magical. I remembered a bag of pastel Peeps tucked away from Easter and decided to experiment. Three different colors later, we had the most technicolor dessert Ive ever created, and rainy Saturdays became our official skillet smore nights.

Ingredients

• 2 cups semi-sweet chocolate chips: The foundation of any respectable smore, and these melt into the perfect consistency for dipping
• 1 tablespoon unsalted butter: This small addition keeps the chocolate smooth and prevents that sad seized texture
• 18 Peeps marshmallow chicks or bunnies: Any color works, but mixing pastels creates the most stunning presentation
• 12 graham crackers, broken into pieces: The essential vessel for transporting molten chocolate to your mouth

Instructions

Preheat and prepare:

Heat your oven to 400°F and grab a 10 inch oven safe skillet while the oven warms up

Melt the chocolate foundation:

Scatter chocolate chips and butter across the skillet bottom, then bake for 3 to 4 minutes until mostly melted

Create a smooth base:

Remove the skillet carefully and give the chocolate a gentle stir until completely combined and glossy

Arrange the Peeps:

Place your marshmallow chicks in a single layer over the chocolate, nestling them close together like a colorful quilt

Toast to golden perfection:

Return to the oven for 4 to 6 minutes, watching closely until Peeps puff up and turn lightly golden brown

The hardest part:

Let the skillet rest for 2 to 3 minutes so the molten chocolate sets slightly and nobody burns their tongue

Dive in together:

Serve immediately with graham cracker pieces and encourage everyone to scoop from different sections

Save to Pinterest

My sister declared this the ultimate birthday dessert after I made it for her thirtieth. Something about nostalgia meeting gourmet makes people absolutely light up. Now it shows up at every celebration, from baby showers to Super Bowl parties, because adults get just as excited about those sugary marshmallows as kids do.

Making It Your Own

I once added peanut butter cups beneath the chocolate layer and my husband still talks about it months later. The salty peanut butter cutting through the sweet marshmallow creates this incredible balance. Other times I sprinkle flaky sea salt over the chocolate before adding Peeps, which transforms it into something restaurant worthy.

The Color Strategy

After several experiments, I learned that clustering the same colors together creates a more dramatic presentation than random mixing. When they toast, each color browns slightly differently, so you get this gorgeous ombré effect. Yellow Peeps seem to toast the most evenly, while pink ones develop these beautiful caramelized spots.

Serving Smarter

The first time I served this, I underestimated how quickly the chocolate would firm up as it cooled. Now I put the skillet right in the center of the table with an oven mitt underneath and let everyone serve themselves family style. The conviviality of dipping from the same skillet creates such a wonderful moment.

• Set out extra graham crackers because one round per person is never enough
• Keep a clean spoon nearby for scooping up those last precious bites
• If the chocolate firms too much, pop the skillet back in the oven for just one minute

Save to Pinterest

There is something genuinely joyous about turning those humble marshmallow chicks into a dessert that makes adults giddy. May your kitchen always smell like toasted sugar and happiness.

Recipes Q&A

→ What type of chocolate works best?

Semi-sweet chocolate chips provide balanced sweetness, but you can substitute milk chocolate for a creamier texture or dark chocolate for deeper flavor intensity.

→ Can I use different marshmallow shapes?

While chicks and bunnies create the traditional look, any Peeps shapes or colors work beautifully. Regular marshmallows can be substituted if seasonal shapes aren't available.

→ How do I prevent the marshmallows from burning?

Keep a close eye during the final 4–6 minutes of baking. The colorful sugar coating can caramelize quickly, so checking at the 4-minute mark ensures perfect toasting without scorching.

→ What else can I use for dipping?

Beyond graham crackers, try vanilla wafers, pretzels for sweet-and-salty contrast, or even fresh strawberries for a fruity twist on this warm chocolatey creation.

→ Can this be made ahead?

For optimal texture, serve immediately while the chocolate remains molten and marshmallows are fluffy. Rewarm briefly at 350°F if needed before serving leftovers.

→ What size skillet should I use?

A 10-inch oven-safe skillet provides ideal surface area for even melting and proper marshmallow coverage. Smaller skillets may crowd the marshmallows, while larger ones thin the chocolate layer.